1. The Short Answer

Sometimes. Amazon as a seller on a listing is the toughest competitor you'll face, but it doesn't sell every product all year, and it runs out of stock.

The decision comes down to three questions. How often is Amazon in stock? Where does your price sit compared to Amazon's? And does the listing sell enough that you get sales when Amazon is out?

If you can't answer all three with data, don't buy. The rest of this post shows how to get the answers in a few minutes per lead.

2. How to Spot Amazon on a Listing

Open the offer list and look for an offer that ships from and is sold by Amazon.com. That's Amazon Retail, buying from the brand or a distributor and selling direct.

On the Keepa graph, Amazon's price shows as its own line and shaded area. Gaps in that shading are periods when Amazon had no stock. The Keepa graphs tutorial shows which line to look at.

"Amazon actually sells their own right now, which is crazy."

Live Online Arbitrage Sourcing | Keepa Storefront Stalking

Amazon shows up on listings you'd never expect, including grocery staples. Check every lead, every time.

3. Why Amazon Is a Hard Competitor

You bought your units at retail sale prices and pay FBA fees on every one. Amazon Retail buys from the brand or a distributor, so it can hold a price you can't match at a profit.

Plan for Amazon to take most of the sales while it's in stock at its price. Your units sell when Amazon runs out, when its price climbs, or when demand outpaces its stock.

"yeah, it's not really going to move really fast for you if you are like because you're competing with Amazon Fresh. you're going to get some sales."

Online Arbitrage Strategy That Actually Makes Money | Day 7 of Sourcing Everyday

"Some sales" can still pay on a high-volume listing. On a slow listing it means your units sit while the aged inventory clock runs. Surcharges start at 181 days and climb with age.

4. Read Amazon's Stock Pattern

Pull the last 90 and 180 days in Keepa and count the out-of-stock gaps in Amazon's line.

  • Amazon in stock almost all the time: pass, unless you can beat its price at a profit.
  • Amazon out of stock for weeks at a time: the listing pays third-party sellers during those windows. Check whether sales rank holds up while Amazon is gone.
  • Amazon in and out every few days: hard to plan around. Buy small or pass.

Pay attention to price behavior in the gaps. If the Buy Box price jumps when Amazon leaves, the third-party sellers on that listing earn their best margins in those windows.

5. Compare Your Price to Amazon's

Work out the lowest price where you still hit your profit and ROI floor. Then compare it to Amazon's current and typical price.

  • Your floor sits below Amazon's price: you can compete head to head. Rare in OA, but it happens on clearance buys.
  • Your floor sits a little above Amazon's price: most of your sales land in Amazon's stock gaps.
  • Your floor sits far above Amazon's price: you only sell when Amazon is out, and other sellers will undercut you then too.

Use the FBA calculator to find your floor and the ROI minimum guide to set it.

6. Volume Decides Whether the Gaps Pay

A listing that sells a few thousand units a month leaves real volume for third-party sellers when Amazon runs short. A listing that sells 60 a month leaves crumbs.

Estimate the sales during Amazon's out-of-stock periods, not the monthly average. Then divide by the sellers who stay competitive in those windows. If your share won't cover your order in a reasonable time, the deal fails no matter how good the ROI looks.

The same unit-share math from how many sellers on a listing is too many applies here, with Amazon counted as the seller that gets first pick.

7. The Holidays Shift the Picture

Amazon's stock and pricing during the holiday rush can look different from what you saw in the fall. Some listings Amazon kept in stock for months run out in December. Some of those come back in January. Others stay out longer.

Don't trust a snapshot from one month. Recheck Amazon's line on any lead you saved in October before you buy into it now, and look at what that line did last November through January. The Keepa Q4 price prediction guide covers how to read holiday price swings.

8. Source Where Amazon Isn't

The easiest fight is the one you skip. Filter for products Amazon doesn't sell before you spend time on analysis.

"And so I'm going to filter the database of products for GAP products that Amazon is not selling, right? And there are 66,000 products."

The Exact System I Use to Find Winning Arbitrage Products on Amazon

Keepa's Product Finder lets you build a filter like that for any brand or retailer. Set it up once with the Keepa Product Finder tutorial.

"Now, the reason why this is the easiest way to make money on Amazon is because usually these websites do not sell themselves on Amazon."

Find Amazon Products That Actually Sell Fast

Retailer house brands are a good place to look. Chris used Vitacost's sale on its own brands in that video as the example.

9. Let Other Sellers Show You the Gaps

Sellers you track tell you which listings pay. An experienced OA seller who adds a product with Amazon on the offer list likely saw a stock pattern worth betting on.

Chris built Arbitrage Stalker to track seller storefronts and alert you when those sellers add products. Treat each alert as a lead to check, not a buy signal. Run the Amazon stock pattern and price checks above on every one.

Prefer doing it by hand first? Amazon storefront stalking walks through the manual version.

10. The Amazon-on-Listing Checklist

Run these before you buy any product with Amazon on the offer list:

  • Amazon was out of stock for meaningful stretches in the last 180 days.
  • Sales rank held up during those out-of-stock stretches.
  • Your profit floor sits close to or below Amazon's typical price.
  • Your share of out-of-stock-period sales covers your order in a reasonable time.
  • You're buying a quantity you can sit on for a few weeks without stress.

Pass on anything that fails two or more. Plenty of listings without Amazon on them are waiting.

Want to watch this check run on live leads? Save a seat at the Thursday training and see how the buy decision gets made.

Free Live Training

Watch me run this system live every Thursday

Every Thursday at 8 PM EST I run a free 60-minute training where I source, analyze, and ship a real product. Reserve a seat and watch the whole thing.

Reserve My Free Seat →

11. Next Steps

These five posts sharpen the rest of your buy decision: