Table of Contents
- The Dispute No One Prepares You For
- What the Buyer Actually Claimed
- Why eBay Sided With Me
- Amazon Makes You Prove a Negative
- Jacob's Account Got Flagged Over a Prep Center
- Amazon's Ask: Prove You're Not Someone Else
- Learn the System Before the Dispute Hits
- The One Big Downside of eBay
- eBay vs Amazon Disputes: The Real Comparison
- Next Steps
1. The Dispute No One Prepares You For
A buyer opened a case against me on eBay claiming my tracking number was fake. He told eBay I fabricated the number and was trying to scam him. In the video above I walk through how eBay handled it, then compare it to what that same situation looks like on Amazon.
eBay and Amazon handle seller disputes differently. If you run an online arbitrage business and sell on both, that gap matters when something goes wrong.
2. What the Buyer Actually Claimed
The package had shipped. It was stuck at a USPS location for a day or two. Carriers have delays. This buyer decided a tracking number not updating in real time was proof of fraud.
His claim to eBay: I sent a fake tracking number to fake a shipment that never went out. You cannot create a fake tracking number that shows up in the USPS system as scanned and in transit. That is not how carrier infrastructure works.
We paid for shipping. The carrier scanned the package. The scan history was in the system. And the buyer accused us of hacking the postal network.
3. Why eBay Sided With Me
"The great thing about eBay...is that eBay is going to side with sellers really easily if you provide evidence that makes sense and really simple evidence where on Amazon, you're going to need to jump through hoops."eBay vs Amazon Seller Disputes: Who Sides With Sellers?
The evidence was carrier scan history showing the package was picked up and moving through the USPS network. eBay looked at that and closed the case in my favor.
eBay's process favors sellers when the documentation is clear. Submit straightforward proof and they close it without a fight.
4. Amazon Makes You Prove a Negative
"The way it works on Amazon is that you're going to prove that you did not do something that you did not do."eBay vs Amazon Seller Disputes: Who Sides With Sellers?
Amazon doesn't ask you to show what you did. They ask you to prove a negative: that you are not connected to something, that your account is not related to another account that did something wrong.
You can't submit a document that says "I didn't do it." You have to build a case around evidence that doesn't exist by definition. Read how Amazon suspension appeals work before this hits you.
5. Jacob's Account Got Flagged Over a Prep Center
One of my students, Jacob, had his Amazon account suspended. Amazon's stated reason: his account was related to another account that was not in good standing.
The only connection was a shared prep center. Jacob lives in the Middle East. The other person lives in Ghana. They had never spoken, never met. A shared prep center address on their inbound shipments was the entire basis for Amazon's suspicion.
Amazon can see overlapping inbound addresses and flag accounts that share one. The other sellers using your prep center become part of your risk profile.
6. Amazon's Ask: Prove You're Not Someone Else
Jacob tracked down the other person and made contact. They showed Amazon documentation proving two separate people on two different continents owned these accounts. Amazon's response was essentially: good, but you still need to prove your account is not related to his.
You can't paper your way out of that. If Jacob hadn't found that person, Amazon would have kept issuing responses that made no sense. Keeping your Amazon account health rating clean doesn't protect you from this. The flag can come from someone else.
7. Learn the System Before the Dispute Hits
Most account issues start with sourcing and prep decisions, not shipping accidents. When you know how to evaluate products and account risk before you buy, you spot problems before they start. That is what I show every week. Grab a free seat at ngunza.com/register before Thursday.
Watch me run this system live every Thursday
Every Thursday at 8 PM EST I run a free 60-minute training where I source, analyze, and ship a real product. Reserve a seat and watch the whole thing.
Reserve My Free Seat →8. The One Big Downside of eBay
"Whenever eBay says something, usually it's just final."eBay vs Amazon Seller Disputes: Who Sides With Sellers?
eBay makes individual disputes easier to win when the evidence is clear. But if eBay suspends or bans your account, there is almost no path back. Daily Refinement, a well-known eBay reseller on YouTube, had this happen. His account was gone with very little recourse. That is how eBay operates.
On Amazon, a suspension is brutal, but you can appeal, submit a plan of action, escalate, or hire a reinstatement professional. On eBay, once the account is gone, it stays gone.
9. eBay vs Amazon Disputes: The Real Comparison
eBay is the better platform for simple buyer disputes. The evidence bar is low, the process moves fast, and a carrier scan history closes most cases.
Amazon disputes are harder in the moment. If your account gets suspended, appeal paths exist and sellers use them. That is why scaling on Amazon FBA is still the better long-term play for serious sellers building real volume.
I covered this comparison in the video above. If you want to understand why I stopped prioritizing eBay growth, I covered that decision in Why I Stopped Scaling My eBay Business on my main channel. Subscribe to MoreGunza for a new video every day.
10. Next Steps
Account protection and dispute resolution go deeper than one post. Five places to continue: